HRO Today Publishes 2026 Customer-Satisfaction Rankings for Screening Providers
HRO Today has released its 2026 Baker’s Dozen Customer Satisfaction Ratings for pre-employment screening, ranking providers using feedback from buyers of their services. The results identify enterprise leaders in overall satisfaction and in three separate categories—breadth of service, size of deals and quality of service—alongside a distinct list of leaders serving midsize programs. For HR teams reviewing screening partners, the rankings offer a buyer-informed point of reference, though they do not replace assessment of an employer’s own requirements.
Enterprise rankings span four measures
In the overall enterprise ranking, the providers appear in this order: JDP, InCheck, AccuSourceHR, Reliable Background Screening, Validity Screening Solutions, Verified Credentials, LLC, Verified First, AB Global, Shield Screening and Cisive. The category lists show that strengths vary by measure. For breadth of service, the order is InCheck, AB Global, Shield Screening, Reliable Background Screening, Verified Credentials, LLC, AccuSourceHR, Verified First, JDP, Validity Screening Solutions and Cisive.
For size of deals, the published order is Cisive, JDP, InCheck, AccuSourceHR, Verified First, Validity Screening Solutions, Shield Screening, Verified Credentials, LLC, AB Global and Reliable Background Screening. In quality of service, JDP leads, followed by InCheck, AccuSourceHR, Validity Screening Solutions, Reliable Background Screening, Verified Credentials, LLC, Verified First, AB Global, Cisive and Shield Screening. The differences across lists matter: a provider’s position in the overall ranking does not necessarily indicate the same relative standing across each individual measure.
The midsize-program list is presented separately and ranks providers by overall score. Its leaders, in published order, are Data Facts Inc., CNet Technologies, Backgrounds Online, FirstPoint, Background Screening Resources and Background Profiles. HRO Today does not provide additional category-level rankings for this group in the supplied results, so the list should be read as an overall ordering rather than as a comparison across the three enterprise measures.
Ratings are built from buyer responses
HRO Today says the Baker’s Dozen ratings rely on feedback from buyers of the services being rated, rather than the publication’s editorial opinion. The annual online survey is distributed directly to buyers through HRO Today mailing lists and indirectly through service providers. Responses are included in the analysis for providers with a statistically significant sample size. The publication does not disclose the number of responses or provider-specific scores in the results presented here, so the rankings do not show the size of the gaps between providers.
To calculate the ratings, HRO Today analyzes responses across service breadth, deal sizes and service quality. A predetermined algorithm weights questions and categories according to their stated importance, producing scores for each measure and an overall score. The publication also says it excludes incomplete responses and surveys it considers outside the normal distribution, including submissions judged implausibly positive or spitefully negative. HRO Today describes the methodology as statistically valid while acknowledging that it is not the only possible approach to provider ratings.
Using the results in screening decisions
Pre-employment screening is one part of the hiring process, and choosing a provider can affect how screening work is delivered across roles and hiring volumes. The separate measures give HR and procurement teams more detail than a single overall list: breadth, deal size and service quality are distinct considerations, and their importance will depend on an employer’s program. The published order can help teams identify providers to examine, but it does not establish that a particular provider is the best fit for every organization.
For a practical comparison, HR teams can use the rankings as an input to their sourcing and review process, then check how a provider’s services align with the organization’s screening needs and operating model. The results are based on customer feedback, not a stated assessment of every technical, legal or operational feature of each service. HRO Today positions the ratings as a resource for the next request for proposal process; buyers still need to evaluate the specific service scope and evidence relevant to their own decision.
The 2026 release therefore offers two types of information: an overall view of enterprise and midsize-program providers, and a breakdown of enterprise rankings by three satisfaction dimensions. Its usefulness rests on treating those rankings as comparative survey findings, not as a substitute for due diligence or a guarantee of future performance. Because the article provides rankings but not underlying scores or sample counts, readers should avoid drawing conclusions about the magnitude of differences between providers.